It depends on the task that you set for yourself. Then the question is, can you tell that "spit" with removed is distinct from initial "b", or do "(s)pit" and "bit" become indistinguishable. It may be useful to gather some good recordings of yourself saying "spit", "pit", "bit" and so on, and perform the editing test, where you (use Praat to) remove the fricative from "spit". The confusion situation is because people do not agree on the criteria for saying what some language sound "really" is – is it a claim about phonological pattern, or a claim about phonetics. Actually, in words like "cabby", "b" is produced with vocal fold vibration. Without some additional feature, and if you are not allowed to say that /b/ is voiced (given the presumption that there is no vocal fold vibration during its production), then you need something to distinguish the labial stops of "pit, bit, spit, happy, cabby". One solution is to invoke an additional property, tense / lax or fortis / lenis, so /p/ is fortis and /b/ is lenis, and then you are free to say that fortis stops can be aspirated in syllable-initial (or foot-initial) position. If we say that "p" is /pʰ/ and "b" is /p/, the description of the allophonic difference between the variants of "p" is harder to explain. It is often said that that /b/ is voiced, but for most speakers it is not always voiced in the way it is in French, so there is an alternative analysis of the phonemic contrast /p,b/ as being one of aspiration (the phoneme "p" is treated as aspirated and "b" is voiceless and unaspirated). The standard mostly-phonological analysis is that "pin" has aspirated and "spin" has unaspirated, but they reflect a single phoneme /p/, which contrasts with /b/. There is phonological analysis, and there is acoustic analysis. Second, it's unclear what you mean by "really". First, there is a lot of variation in English, so don't expect the facts to be the same for all speakers.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. ArchivesCategories |